Detonation, Fuel Cut, or Something Else?
Moderators: Helpinators, Moderators
-
- First Gear
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Wed Oct 16, 2002 10:50 pm
- Location: Hilliard, OH
Detonation, Fuel Cut, or Something Else?
I just upped the boost for the first time yesterday. The only mod I have is a Saab 900 intercooler. We figured 10psi would be a good place to put it. Well, it was at 10psi in 1st and was slightly higher in each succeeding gear. In 5th gear it was at 12psi. I was a bit weary of letting the turbo spool up to 12, but figured what the hey. Not even 2 seconds while at 12 pounds, the car acted like I ran out of gas. It was the same feeling I had last week when autocrossing, and took a long, wide right turn into a slalom. I'm not sure what detonation or fuel cut feels like or sounds like, so could someone help me out?
Andy Rose
1993 Subaru Legacy Sport Sedan
2003 Subaru Impreza WRX
2004 Subaru Impreza WRX STI
1999 Hyundai Accent
1993 Subaru Legacy Sport Sedan
2003 Subaru Impreza WRX
2004 Subaru Impreza WRX STI
1999 Hyundai Accent
sounds like your ecu is displaying fuel cut off which will happen at around 12 psi. does it rather abruptly cut out and then come back but with less power. 12 psi should be fine for the stock turbo espeially with an intercooler and at least 91 octane fuel. it is just really annoying. get a reprogrammed chip, programeable ecu, afcr, or fcd. most liklely that is what it is. is that how you would describe it?
-
- Fourth Gear
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2002 9:53 pm
- Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, Now Sioux Lookout
I Don't think its detonation. You wont really feel any difference in power when the motor is detonating, the only difference is a sound like small pebbles in a tin can. Boost/fuel cut is an ubrupt on/off in power feeling, like asthough the ignition is turned off. When you ease up on the throttle power will come back on. Very noticable. Factory boost cut is activated at 13 psi. I think your feeling fuel cut, as most guages aren't perfectly accurate, the 12psi or so you see on your guage may actually be 13 psi read by the ECU. You can always turn the boost down 1-2 psi or get a FCD if you want to go above fuel cut.
Mark,
Mark,
Last edited by LegacyT on Thu Apr 17, 2003 1:57 am, edited 1 time in total.
1991 Turbo Sedan, Aspen White 5MT, Sold RIP
1994 Turbo Sedan, Crimson Pearl 5MT, from British Columbia-no rust!
1994 Turbo Sedan, Crimson Pearl 5MT, from British Columbia-no rust!
-
- Second Gear
- Posts: 478
- Joined: Wed Mar 26, 2003 4:23 am
- Location: Troy, Ohio / Toronto, Ontario
- Contact:
sounds like fuel cut to me as well. In reference to your auto-x incident with the lack of power on a long sweeping turn. All subarus apparently get that when running a quarter tank or less of gas. Happened to every suby last year at one event, until we realized that the gas went to one side of the tank and wasn't getting picked up by the pump. Can't remember if it only happens when you turn one way or if it's in both directions. Anyways food for though.
good luck
good luck
Nuwan
1992 Open Class Legacy Turbo
2004 Forester XT
2000 Impreza 2.5RSC (Supercharged)
1990 Rover Mini 1000
1992 Open Class Legacy Turbo
2004 Forester XT
2000 Impreza 2.5RSC (Supercharged)
1990 Rover Mini 1000
-
- First Gear
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Wed Oct 16, 2002 10:50 pm
- Location: Hilliard, OH
I am using a mbc. I'm not sure what kind. It's actually just a loner until I can get one. It was an abrupt hesitation. As soon as it happened, I let off the gas and didn't let it get up there again. I turned it down just a bit. Now, it gets a little past 10 pounds in 5th gear. About the auto-x, I did have less than 1/4 tank. I figured I was getting starvation when it happened. I don't know, I may be a little too cautious, but I didn't race after it hesitated the second time at the track. Are there any negative effects of fuel cut or starvation?
Andy Rose
1993 Subaru Legacy Sport Sedan
2003 Subaru Impreza WRX
2004 Subaru Impreza WRX STI
1999 Hyundai Accent
1993 Subaru Legacy Sport Sedan
2003 Subaru Impreza WRX
2004 Subaru Impreza WRX STI
1999 Hyundai Accent
-
- Second Gear
- Posts: 266
- Joined: Wed Oct 16, 2002 6:57 am
- Location: North Bend, Wa
sounds exactly like fuel cut.
where's your gauge tapped? depending on the location of the tap for the boost gauge, you might be seeing something different than the MAP is seeing. and yeah, gauges aren't always right on. mine's about .05 MPa off . and that's genuine subaru parts (wrx boost gauge)
where's your gauge tapped? depending on the location of the tap for the boost gauge, you might be seeing something different than the MAP is seeing. and yeah, gauges aren't always right on. mine's about .05 MPa off . and that's genuine subaru parts (wrx boost gauge)
IggDawg is cool.
-IggDawg
1994 Barcelona Red SVX LSi.
1990 CRX Si (for sale)
I know a little about Subarus.
-IggDawg
1994 Barcelona Red SVX LSi.
1990 CRX Si (for sale)
I know a little about Subarus.
RE: Fuel starvation - It doesn't happen with every Scoob. It would happen to me in my old RS with less than 1/4 tank on sweeping right turns. In my WRX on race tires (which is setup enough for me to take 2nd out of 81, 1st out of 120-ish, and 2nd out of 140 at recent autox's), I've run down to about a gallon left in the tank and never had fuel starvation.
91 Turbo Legacy Sedan 5MT
02 Impreza WRX Sedan 5MT
02 Legacy Sedan 5MT
02 Impreza WRX Sedan 5MT
02 Legacy Sedan 5MT
-
- First Gear
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Wed Oct 16, 2002 10:50 pm
- Location: Hilliard, OH
You can bypass the fuel-cut "phenomena", by making a small (1mm) hole to the pressure regulator vacuum hose. The small ticking "canister" inside the right fender (- about the size of a 35mm film canister.)
This is done easiest by installing a plastic connector to the middle of the hose and then burning (melting) a small hole with a heated needle to it.
This 1mm hole will lessen the actual pressure in the regulator by appr. 0,2bar (psi???), and thus preventing accidental fuel-cut dependent of air temperature and humidity - and also preventing fuel-cut in case your turbo has a high peak boost before settling to normal.
Bu sure to have a accurate boost gauge, so that you know what boost youre running. The EJ20 (or EJ22) can take safely 1,3 bar boost with a 98 octane (the highher pump octane in Finland, the lower is 95). With american 92 oct you could expect reasonable safe level of 1.0 bar without knocking.
This is done easiest by installing a plastic connector to the middle of the hose and then burning (melting) a small hole with a heated needle to it.
This 1mm hole will lessen the actual pressure in the regulator by appr. 0,2bar (psi???), and thus preventing accidental fuel-cut dependent of air temperature and humidity - and also preventing fuel-cut in case your turbo has a high peak boost before settling to normal.
Bu sure to have a accurate boost gauge, so that you know what boost youre running. The EJ20 (or EJ22) can take safely 1,3 bar boost with a 98 octane (the highher pump octane in Finland, the lower is 95). With american 92 oct you could expect reasonable safe level of 1.0 bar without knocking.
Legacy 200 STW MY92
-
- Vikash
- Posts: 12517
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2002 2:13 am
- Location: USA, OH, Cleveland (sometimes visiting DC though)
- Contact:
Teesaa, just to clarify, I think you mean the pressure exchange solenoid, not the pressure regulator solenoid.
The pressure exchange solenoid is right above the boost control solenoid; both are cylindricalish in shape. The pressure exchange solenoid is brown plastic, and has three vacuum lines coming off it. One is short and goes straight to the pressure sensor (little square black plastic thing), one has a little cylindrical air filter installed directly on it, and one goes to the manifold. That last line is the one to put the bleed into.
The pressure exchange solenoid is right above the boost control solenoid; both are cylindricalish in shape. The pressure exchange solenoid is brown plastic, and has three vacuum lines coming off it. One is short and goes straight to the pressure sensor (little square black plastic thing), one has a little cylindrical air filter installed directly on it, and one goes to the manifold. That last line is the one to put the bleed into.
-
- Fourth Gear
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2002 9:53 pm
- Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, Now Sioux Lookout
Ok so you install this little contraption on the vacuum line that goes from the intake manifold to the right hand side of the pressure exchange solenoid (brown thingy)? My boost guage is tapped into this line, will doing this give inaccurate readings?
Mark,
Mark,
1991 Turbo Sedan, Aspen White 5MT, Sold RIP
1994 Turbo Sedan, Crimson Pearl 5MT, from British Columbia-no rust!
1994 Turbo Sedan, Crimson Pearl 5MT, from British Columbia-no rust!
-
- Vikash
- Posts: 12517
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2002 2:13 am
- Location: USA, OH, Cleveland (sometimes visiting DC though)
- Contact:
By "right hand side" you mean the side pointing towards the engine, right? If so, that's correct.
You may get inaccurate readings on your boost gauge; to minimize it I'd suggest putting the bleeder as close as possible to the solenoid, and putting the tee to your boost gauge as close as possible to the manifold. With it set up that way you should be fine.
Usually you want your gauge as close as possible to the manifold anyway, to see what the engine's actually ingesting.
You may get inaccurate readings on your boost gauge; to minimize it I'd suggest putting the bleeder as close as possible to the solenoid, and putting the tee to your boost gauge as close as possible to the manifold. With it set up that way you should be fine.
Usually you want your gauge as close as possible to the manifold anyway, to see what the engine's actually ingesting.
-
- Vikash
- Posts: 12517
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2002 2:13 am
- Location: USA, OH, Cleveland (sometimes visiting DC though)
- Contact:
Where you should tap pressure for your boost gauge depends on what you want to measure. Tapping the compressor outlet will tell you what pressure the turbocharger itself is producing. Tapping just before the throttle will tell you the pressure that the engine would see if there were no throttle (basically the turbo outlet minus intake/intercooler pressure drop). Tapping from the intake manifold (the most common one) tells you what pressure or vacuum your engine is seeing. It's good to be able to keep an eye on your engine's manifold vacuum and pressure, so that's where I put it.
Compressor outlet pressure isn't always as meaningful when the throttle isn't fully opened. Or at least not as meaningful to me, since I'm not smart enough to make use of it. :)
Compressor outlet pressure isn't always as meaningful when the throttle isn't fully opened. Or at least not as meaningful to me, since I'm not smart enough to make use of it. :)
-
- Second Gear
- Posts: 428
- Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 3:45 am
- Location: Brisbane, Australia
- Contact:
be careful when bleeding off air to the map sensor, if you bleed off too much it will run super rich upon startup (especially when cold) and will lean out under manifold pressure (boost) i suggest using an adjustable bleed valve to do this and go up in small increments or get it dynoed and done proffesionally. I have the australian RS Liberty with water air intercooler. factory boost cut on mine is set to 14.7psi with the adjustable bleed valve on the map sensor i have it set to 17psi boost cut. I fully have to warm my car up on startup because if I take off and drive it like I stole it when I first jump in it will actually begin to foul plugs because it runs richer down low and it will run a bit leaner at boost.
-
- Vikash
- Posts: 12517
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2002 2:13 am
- Location: USA, OH, Cleveland (sometimes visiting DC though)
- Contact:
The Legacy Turbo -- the North American BC/BF turbo at least -- doesn't really fuel based on the pressure sensor. You certainly won't get overly rich mixtures at startup or overly lean mixtures at boost.
At boost, you will get mixtures that are less rich than they were specified to be by the ECU engineers, though.
You should be aware that a bleeder is basically the same as the fuel cut defenders that change the slope of the voltage vs. pressure curve rather than clamping the voltage. When your manifold pressure is 10psi, for example, the ECU may think it's only 9psi. So, it would retard timing and enrich the mixture less than it probably should.
Note that this is does not mean the ECU will inject the appropriate amount of fuel for 9psi. Fueling is primarily based on the MAF sensor, so the mixture will still be much richer than the stoichiometric. It just won't be as much richer.
At boost, you will get mixtures that are less rich than they were specified to be by the ECU engineers, though.
You should be aware that a bleeder is basically the same as the fuel cut defenders that change the slope of the voltage vs. pressure curve rather than clamping the voltage. When your manifold pressure is 10psi, for example, the ECU may think it's only 9psi. So, it would retard timing and enrich the mixture less than it probably should.
Note that this is does not mean the ECU will inject the appropriate amount of fuel for 9psi. Fueling is primarily based on the MAF sensor, so the mixture will still be much richer than the stoichiometric. It just won't be as much richer.