Page 1 of 1

Is This quote good?

Posted: Sat Jun 10, 2006 8:29 pm
by lleiro
Hi everybody, this is my first post here and I hope I will enjoy been in this forum, and I can be part of it.

I am getting my 95 Legacy Brighton wagon to the shop in the new york area and I get a quote of $680 to replace the timing belt, tensioneer kit a water pump.

Do you think this is a good quote or is it a liitle bit too high?

I will appreciate you answer a lot.

Thanks!

Posted: Sat Jun 10, 2006 9:32 pm
by evolutionmovement
Around here that's really high. Parts prices from subaruparts.com would run you about $225 and figure even two hours labor (which is a little generous) and you're down under $450. Granted, local dealer parts are more so factor another $150 for that. It's an easy job and if you're replacing the tensioner they come new already pinned so you don't even need to compress the sucker.

Posted: Sun Jun 11, 2006 1:34 am
by Legacy777
How many miles on the car? I'd recommend replacing the oil seals while you're in there.

2 hours is a little tight IMO. Sure it can be done in 2 hours, but they'll probably go with whatever the book time is for the t-belt job.

However, that price is a little high IMO....but it may not be for NYC

Posted: Sun Jun 11, 2006 3:21 am
by evolutionmovement
Don't know what the book is, but I've had it done (minus the tensioner - $78 @ subaruparts.com, $145 local dealer - no extra labor) for $250. Even factoring in typical $90-$100 shop labor rates vs. my mechanic's $60 that's still really high.

Posted: Sun Jun 11, 2006 9:12 pm
by lleiro
The thing is that I won the car on ebay for $450 and I am getting the vibe that the seller is trying to overcharge me on the repair because is not satisfied with the final bid, Last Year I had another Mechanic here in South carolina who replace the seals and the timing belt for $280 and now I get this $700 quote and I am not enjoying it.

The car has 139k miles and it is unusually rusty in some places that I've never seen before.

Any way,

I guess I will call some local dealer near NYC and have more info to make a conclusion about the seller's intentions.

Thanks a lot for your help since you provided me with technical information that the dealers won't disclose.


PS: The quote was actually $700 not $680