Old Subarus that I've seen are virtually never leaking from the rear main.
You all could be right, it could be the separator plate. I should indicate though that the residue is distributed pretty evenly across the bottom, and the separator plate is on the passenger side of the engine IIRC.
When I get around to it, I'll be pulling the engine instead, for a number of reasons.
First, I'm thinking of possibly going NA tuned on this car, maybe some headwork and cams, slight fuel upgrades, minor EM, etc. If I do, I'd like to see 170-180chp.
Then again, I probably won't. Regardless, the valve guides are leaking slightly also... I'm losing a quart of oil every 1k miles, and I know my oil pump and rear main/separator plate/whatever are not leaking THAT much.
Steve, I believe you said that it's possible to change valve guides without pulling the heads? I'd also like to get new HLA's too, as mine still tap slightly at idle, even when I have the oil topped off.
I'll also want a new clutch by then.
And also, two of the holes in the body for tranny Xmember bolts were stripped out and I rethreaded them. So far, they're holding up with Loctite, and if possible, I'd like not to mess with that.
At the VERY least, this won't happen until after I graduate anyway. And I've got more important things to tend to once that happens, namely wheel bearings (

), body work, and FINALLY getting the A/C working again.