I thought it may have been warped, because at idle it had a little 'wiggle' to it. I bought and installed a replacement just this week. Turns out that the wiggle must be in my crank, which means this pulley is actually good.
It's red anodized, and I spent about $80 on it. It has a few scratches where the crank bolt seated against, and there is a bit of discoloration in the anodization. All in all, I could let it go for about $60 shipped.



The best pic I could get of the discoloration. My camera didn't wanna focus too well.
