Legacy777 wrote:Not all Mech engineers are like that......however there are a lot like that. I am not one of them

Well you are into Subaru's so you obviously have a clue

All I am saying is that most (and I'm using that loosely) ME's have this strange personal god complex with their designs where their judgment and focus on the final product becomes clouded with their own personal wet dreams on making something cooler or more complex than it needs to be thus making it harder to manufacture which translates to higher cost.
I worked with a ME that could not make a prox bracket out of a piece of bar stock with 2 holes in it. What I mean is that all we "needed" was a prox to hang over a conveyor and sense a gear go by. Easy enough right? Well you could make a bracket out of bar stock for $10 material and labor max. But no this prick would spend 2 days designing a 3d model of some intricate aluminum bracket that required 5 or 6 different milling operations to produce and had 3 different radii on different surfaces and a notch and all this extra bullshit that had nothing to do with the function. so, it would take him 2 days to design (do the math based on what you make average an hour), then it would take maybe 3-4 hours to make in the machine shop (do the math), then you have the cost of the aluminum (do the math). A $10 dollar part ends up costing $300 dollars. Not to mention that the time is considerably longer before an assembler can put the part on which pushes the whole project back.
I had asked this guy one time if he could reduce the amount of operations on his designs to reduce the cost. His answer "I'm aways within my design budget". The problem with this is that the more complicated this shit was to make the more time it took the purchasing department to make it, thus delaying the project. But they didn't give a shit because they delivered the design on time.
Now, I would say that perhaps I just worked for a messed up company but I also dealt with A LOT of ME's with my work in the years and they were all the same.
I'm going on 355 days since my layoff, do you think I am still bitter?